The Results | Collaborating with ChatGPT: A Playful Spin on Vintage Verse

April 20, 2023
Image
limericks from osa

UPDATE:

Did you catch the bot? Below are the answers! Check your answers using the email you were sent after submitting the survey!

Flip open the boxes below to reveal the answers! Or if you'd still like to test yourself, the button below will continue to take you to the survey. After completing it, check your answers using the email you receive!

Breakdown of the Results

A total of 21 guesses were submitted with the following percentage breakdown correct (using the author name to identify the limerick, in order, as below)

Kebabian – 67% correct

Richards – 71% correct

Hall – 57% correct

MacDonald – 62% correct

Nisenson – 86% correct

Seliger – 71% correct

A)

See old Michelson looking for fringes.
When the telescope shakes, how he cringes!
And the turbulent air,
Makes him tear out his hair,
And get drunk on the wildest of binges.

B)

There was an old physicist named Michelson,
Whose search for fringes was never done.
But the telescope’s quiver,
Made him need a stiff liver,
So, he drank and got tipsy for fun.

A)

See old Michelson looking for fringes.
When the telescope shakes, how he cringes!
And the turbulent air,
Makes him tear out his hair,
And get drunk on the wildest of binges.

P. Kebabian

B)

There was an old physicist named Michelson,
Whose search for fringes was never done.
But the telescope’s quiver,
Made him need a stiff liver,
So, he drank and got tipsy for fun.

ChatGPT

A)

Sir Isaac, the king of optics and light,
Would scrub in the tub with all his might.
For an hour or more,
He’d clean and explore,
To avoid those pesky Newtonian rings in sight.

B)

Sir Isaac was one of those kings,
Of optics and other bright things.
But when he took a shower,
He’s scrub for an hour,
On his tub to avoid Newton’s rings.

A)

Sir Isaac, the king of optics and light,
Would scrub in the tub with all his might.
For an hour or more,
He’d clean and explore,
To avoid those pesky Newtonian rings in sight.

ChatGPT

B)

Sir Isaac was one of those kings,
Of optics and other bright things.
But when he took a shower,
He’s scrub for an hour,
On his tub to avoid Newton’s rings.

D.A. Richards

A)

Though a Michelson interferometer is neat,
And with a Golay bolometer it can measure heat,
For a grilled hamburger’s fate,
A thermometer is first-rate,
As the tool that’s reliable and hard to defeat.

B)

Though a Michelson interferometer,
Equipped with a Golay bolometer,
Could measure the heat,
In grilled hamburger meat,
It will never replace the thermometer.

A)

Though a Michelson interferometer is neat,
And with a Golay bolometer it can measure heat,
For a grilled hamburger’s fate,
A thermometer is first-rate,
As the tool that’s reliable and hard to defeat.

ChatGPT

B)

Though a Michelson interferometer,
Equipped with a Golay bolometer,
Could measure the heat,
In grilled hamburger meat,
It will never replace the thermometer.

F.F. Hall

A)

In the lab, it’s essential to say,
An optical hammer can go a long way.
With a light tap or a slight knock,
It can ensure your setup is no shock,
And your measurements won’t go astray.

B)

There is no faint penumbra of doubt,
In the lab one should not be without,
A light optical hammer,
To give things a slam,
Or that final adjustment, a clout.

A)

In the lab, it’s essential to say,
An optical hammer can go a long way.
With a light tap or a slight knock,
It can ensure your setup is no shock,
And your measurements won’t go astray.

ChatGPT

B)

There is no faint penumbra of doubt,
In the lab one should not be without,
A light optical hammer,
To give things a slam,
Or that final adjustment, a clout.

R. I. MacDonald

A)

In Science, I say almost gaily,
New discoveries are made nearly daily.
But in Optics, it’s true,
There is nothing new.
‘Twas all done before by Lord Rayleigh.

B)

Each day in science, I do declare,
New discoveries are made beyond compare.
Yet in optics, it’s been found,
Little is there to astound,
For Lord Rayleigh’s done it all with flair.

A)

In Science, I say almost gaily,
New discoveries are made nearly daily.
But in Optics, it’s true,
There is nothing new.
‘Twas all done before by Lord Rayleigh.

P. Nisenson

B)

Each day in science, I do declare,
New discoveries are made beyond compare.
Yet in optics, it’s been found,
Little is there to astound,
For Lord Rayleigh’s done it all with flair.

ChatGPT

A)

A photon emitted from Sirius,
Followed a path quite mysterious.
For this quantum of action,
By gravitational attraction,
Passed near a black hole and disappearedious.

B)

A photon once left Sirius so bright,
And followed a path of curious light.
It encountered a black hole’s bend,
Where its journey came to an end,
Lost to the attraction’s mighty bite.

A)

A photon emitted from Sirius,
Followed a path quite mysterious.
For this quantum of action,
By gravitational attraction,
Passed near a black hole and disappearedious.

B. Seliger

B)

A photon once left Sirius so bright,
And followed a path of curious light.
It encountered a black hole’s bend,
Where its journey came to an end,
Lost to the attraction’s mighty bite.

ChatGPT


With today’s vast advancements in technology, we now have access to a wealth of knowledge and resources at our fingertips. One such technology that has become extremely popular is ChatGPT, a language model developed by OpenAI that uses deep learning algorithms to generate human-like responses to text-based questions. With its vast knowledge-base and ability to adapt to various topics, ChatGPT is being used for everything from answering trivia questions to the development of customer service chatbots.

As someone who enjoys writing, I was skeptical of using ChatGPT but, ultimately, decided to give it a try for some lighthearted experimentation. I asked ChatGPT to rewrite a few limericks composed by members of the Optical Society of America (OSA/Optica) during a 1976 meeting held in Tucson. * What are your thoughts? Can you identify which limerick is the original and which is ChatGPT’s contemporary take?

After you click the big red button below to play and submit your guesses, you'll receive an email with your guesses so that you can refer to them when we reveal the bot limericks in the next Watts Up! on April 20th. See how well you can pick out the AI poet then!

* Original limericks published in “Optical Sciences Center Weekly,” 10-29-1976 and 11-5-1976.

Prof or Bot?
Click to Guess!